A week after the publication of the Rossi Report, the
turmoil continues but we already can start to build a vision of the general
situation, asking: who confronts whom and what.
Let’s start with the worse one; at first sight you surely
do not realize the horror of it.
Rossi confronts real problems, enemies, competition
and this is natural for such a difficult and challenging research project like
his- but now also belonging to Industrial Heat and, in part to Elforsk.
a) The
professors have obtained unique surprising results now, for the first time;
b) Rossi
has worked for some 3+ years and has never analyzed the ash, or has obtained
different results;
c) Here it
is some big lie- the unique good variant is the results of the Test were
actually expected but Rossi still cannot or will not explain them.
I am totally confused
by this problem.
This is a crucial
problem; for the time given- as far as I know- the authors have not answered a
single question at a special forum organized for this.
Rossi declares very
clearly on his blog that he will NOT answer any question regarding the reactor
and the test- niente! So he does not confront more the questions of those curious
people discontented with some aspects or details of the test.
So many questions will remain unanswered. But
this still is not so troubling as Rossi’ amazement with those isotopic
changes.
Rossi gives us (the
public) fragments of information, as pieces of a puzzle. Those who have other
pieces of the puzzle (supposedly Industrial Heat, Elforsk) can
reconstitute a bigger piece and
understand the situation we remain with half-truths or in the best case with
Pareto truths- and this is endemic for LENR, see: http://egooutpeters.blogspot.ro/2012/11/80-of-all-truths-are-pareto-truths.html
The Report confronts: many angry attackers and the
assertion “it was a remarkable achievement”again is a Pareto Truth. One test, one reactor (as I
commented yesterday) calorimetry in rather unusual conditions, no more
alternative methods used for calorimetry, no verification, re-verification and
cross verification. I know two colleagues who are unable to swallow the 1400 C
temperature- plus red glowing plus nickel melted for sure in some places.
Reality is not homogeneous; there are hot spots in many places. It smells of
disaster.
We are a family of chemists- my
wife and my daughter are specialized in analytical chemistry, I am a chemical
engineer
We know from practice that sampling and sample preparation is the most difficult
part of the analysis and it is so easy to obtain non-relevant and
non-representative samples and results. And what has happened with the sampling
after the test? I may not use 4-letter words here. The problem is – and Rossi
will not let us know- was a correct sample taken too, analyzed and evaluated?
And are there insides who know the complete results?
Rossi and his new nuclear physicist
collaborator need his information for the TRUE THEORY promised by Rossi
And for a patent if he really wants
one…
People who invested hopes this new
source of energy are confronted with this situation:
No absolute certainty of getting
this energy, the test indicates with high probability (taking in account the
first test too) good excess heat- Rossi is right that only the commercial
generators will bring certainty;
It is a VUCA situation (Volatile
(changing, Uncertain (not much predictable things and evolutions), Complex (positive
and negative as Siamese Twins), Ambiguous (friends and enemies both claiming
victory). The VUCAWorld of what is now LENR will last more than we wish.
http://egooutpeters.blogspot.ro/2014/07/the-vuca-world-of-lenr-how-long-it-will.html
Interesting: a reader called Amos-
I believe he is from South Africa commented on my blog (thanks!):
Either
way, the next few months in the LENR space will be quite interesting thanks to
this report. Remember I told you 2014 will not be the year of LENR as you had
postulated. I still maintain that 2015 / 2016 will be the year. Wonder what
Randall Mills thinks of the E-Cat now.
He can
be right, I have my reasons (77 of them) to be in hurry. As regarding Randy, I
can ask him but it is just a formality. Who believed in the functionality of
the E-cat continues to believe after this test and is happier but this 32 days
test not converted many -skeptics in E-cat lovers.
Do not ignore competition- it
comes! There are scientists able to understand even those mysterious isotopic
shifts and know the complete scenario and are adept in controlling the energy
release…
No more scientific experiments like
this one says Rossi but even in his camp surprises are possible. What will do
Elforsk?
I have full empathy for he testers who
have risked much, get tons of insults, I wait for an opportunity to express it
to them directly.
Peter
No comments:
Post a Comment