MOTTO
A harmful truth is better than a useful lie. (Thomas Mann)
Order and simplification are the first steps toward the mastery of a subject.
(Thomas Mann)
DAILY NOTES
a) The recurrent and continuous demonization of Andrea Rossi - amplified as 1MWgeddon is coming
Radical Mary Yugo has called him "sociopath". A reader said he is history's greatest scammer- will show nothing, will obtain no usable results but will be celebrated as a hero. Now again Brian Ahern tells his opinion about Andrea Rossi who also can be a second Prometheus- IF right and shows Rossi's malefic side- frightening. Please ignore that Brian mixes Rossi with Randy Mills whose BLPgeddon will come this Thursday:
"The ability for Andrea Rossi and Randall Mills to attract and maintain support may have a common thread. They may share some of the abilities employed by Donald Trump in his book, The Art of the Deal'. Trump attributes his success to practices employed during hypnosis. There are ways to assure compliance.
LENR folks have been baffled by the poor performance of the scientists in the Lugano testing. How could they fail to use thermocouples? Why are they silent about the report?
We can advance the concept that Andrea and Randall are very persuasive and they cull their audience to keep only the 'most suggestible people. Once selected they can be cajoled into behaving in a manner pleasing to Rossi and/or Mills.
The scientists would be unaware of the undue influence and their actions wqere not devious; they were unduly influenced by the impressarios.
Many of the E-cat followers may have already succumbed to this phenomenon. "
b) Ordinary matter really not good as N.A.E., but...
See please the second Motto by Thomas Mann (the first one is about honesty), applying it to LENR order is the taxonomy we must build for the whole field and simplification surely does not include cutting of parts of truth. Paradoxically simplification is serene acceptance of the complexity and diversity of the LENR phenomena.
At this high level of interestingness, Occam's Razor has to be used (if) with extreme precautions.
I want to insert here a remark: in scientific thinking , discussions it is fair and useful to avoid:"then it must be" because sometimes human logic and Nature's logic- also called Reality can differ, Better say it may be because Nature's logic prevails always.
Mother Nature is a lady with an strong alpha character. Next month I will celebrate the 50 years wedding anniversary with a lady having the same character, so I am well documented.
Sorry for this rather long introduction, actually - in the frame of the LENR Review, I want to tell what I accept and what I NOT reject but replace with other ideas in and for the Ed Storms's LENR theory.
Ed says:
"nuclear reactions do not and can not be made to occur in a normal chemical structure without applied energy..."
"for LENR to take place, something very unusual must form in the material as the site of the fusion process, i.e. the NAE..."
"N.A.E. is rare condition..."
I agree 120% with the first two statements and 100% with the third. Justification: I have arrived to similar conclusions- active sites- as Ed. However the third condition is a reality that has to be changed- there are no technologies based on rare conditions.
Simplifying i.e. condensing and anticipating a bit, Ed's theses can be re-formulated in
-LENR does not take place in ordinary matter
- LENR before being nuclear physics is smart materials science;
We have to learn and apply the science and art of NAE-genesis.
Now everything depends on the nature of those N.A.E.; what and how can they be?
Edmund Storms has given a surprising answer:
"if the nuclear reactions cannot take place in ordinary matter, they must happen in extraordinary voids"
The reason is obvious- the local axiom in PdD based on solid experimental data is that the excess heat is correlated with formation oh helium and the D+D =He is considered the source of excess heat, fusion can take place in a free space.
This is an explosive subject but is there absolute certainty of DIRECT fusion?
OK, let's better continue..if this is true then the hydroton has to be invoked for a mechanism of deuterium fusion. For H+H=D it is possible in principle, but in direct contradiction with Piantelli et al 's many experimental results and it seems the Rossi process is also - different.
I have opted long ago for nuclear reactions taking place in extraordinary matter.
It is so well known and i have learned a lot from Piantelli- the magic stuff is nanostructures with properties that are very different from those of the bulk material,.it is both a science and an art to know what these differences are and how to make them useful for your specific scientific technological task- in this case energy generation.
. Nanostructures is more a generic term that does not describe the exact structure for obtaining discrete energy levels and not energy bands- better also for showing the exchange and correlation energies. More simply told, the structures’s behavior has to be thus of giant atoms
Good nanostructures seem to be a necessary but still not sufficient condition of massive excess heat. How they actually work- nanoplasminics has to be included. The structures are quantum domains in which many things become possible- as the collective nuclear phenomena described by Urutskoev.
PdD and NiH may be different LENR variants. Or not - to finish in an optimist manner.
c) Randy Mills' possible BLPgeddon is coming Thursday
Comment from one of his supporters:
http://egooutpeters.blogspot.ro/2016/01/jan-23-2016-its-better-for-lenr-if-pdd.html?showComment=1453694051648#c1504360708647396099
DAILY NEWS
1) Andrea Rossi
January 24th, 2016 at 9:16 PM
Joe:
Sunday, 09.15 p.m. of Jan 24 2016:
1MW E-Cat good girl: allows me to watch the Panthers, fingers crossed.
E-Cat X resisting to the destructive attempt, good sign.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
http://bishophill.squarespace.com/discussion/post/2564294
4) Stepan Demura: Rossi's generator energetic revolution Степан Демура. Генератор Росси - энергетическая революция. Daily Reporter 24 http://dailyreporter24.com/archives/86210/
5) Paul Mahler at LENR Forum has discovered an 2013 LENR paper by Mahadeva Srinivasan:
"FOCAL THEME : BUILDING AN ECOLOGICALLY SUSTAINABLE SOCIETY" (Social Science Abstracts - Volume XXXVII, 2013 )
by INDIAN ACADEMY OF SOCIAL SCIENCES INDIA
it is the papers of the "XXXVII Indian Social Science Congress"
amu.ac.in/newevent/event/9861.pdf
at pages 61-63 there is an article by Mahadeva Srinivasan on LENR
A harmful truth is better than a useful lie. (Thomas Mann)
Order and simplification are the first steps toward the mastery of a subject.
(Thomas Mann)
DAILY NOTES
a) The recurrent and continuous demonization of Andrea Rossi - amplified as 1MWgeddon is coming
Radical Mary Yugo has called him "sociopath". A reader said he is history's greatest scammer- will show nothing, will obtain no usable results but will be celebrated as a hero. Now again Brian Ahern tells his opinion about Andrea Rossi who also can be a second Prometheus- IF right and shows Rossi's malefic side- frightening. Please ignore that Brian mixes Rossi with Randy Mills whose BLPgeddon will come this Thursday:
"The ability for Andrea Rossi and Randall Mills to attract and maintain support may have a common thread. They may share some of the abilities employed by Donald Trump in his book, The Art of the Deal'. Trump attributes his success to practices employed during hypnosis. There are ways to assure compliance.
LENR folks have been baffled by the poor performance of the scientists in the Lugano testing. How could they fail to use thermocouples? Why are they silent about the report?
We can advance the concept that Andrea and Randall are very persuasive and they cull their audience to keep only the 'most suggestible people. Once selected they can be cajoled into behaving in a manner pleasing to Rossi and/or Mills.
The scientists would be unaware of the undue influence and their actions wqere not devious; they were unduly influenced by the impressarios.
Many of the E-cat followers may have already succumbed to this phenomenon. "
This has suddenly reminded me a short novel of one of my favorite writers:
"Mario and the Magician" by Thomas Mann, see:
A malefic hypnotist Cipolla (symbolizing the dictators of that age, 1929) is using his ability to humiliate, dominate and mislead people; eventually he is killed by young Mario one of his victims. At a writer of Mann's caliber it is not so much what he tells but how he tells it. He learns us to hate Cipollas. The XX-th Century had lots of them.
As an aside the negative resonance of the name Cipolla (Onion) has been converted to the reverse due to a real genius, the economist Carlo M.Cipolla and his bright
Basic Laws of Human Stupidity - see a video presentation here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lqEfSGxC3dM
So, Rossi is hypnotising his victims and is able to do this using the Internet too.
Mary Yugo considers me too as one of his mesmerised victims.
As promised if Rossi fails, I will do virtual intellectual seppuku- abandon LENR and start studying comparative linguistics and proverbs.
However if he has massive excess heat with certainty- what will his detractors say/do?
b) Ordinary matter really not good as N.A.E., but...
See please the second Motto by Thomas Mann (the first one is about honesty), applying it to LENR order is the taxonomy we must build for the whole field and simplification surely does not include cutting of parts of truth. Paradoxically simplification is serene acceptance of the complexity and diversity of the LENR phenomena.
At this high level of interestingness, Occam's Razor has to be used (if) with extreme precautions.
I want to insert here a remark: in scientific thinking , discussions it is fair and useful to avoid:"then it must be" because sometimes human logic and Nature's logic- also called Reality can differ, Better say it may be because Nature's logic prevails always.
Mother Nature is a lady with an strong alpha character. Next month I will celebrate the 50 years wedding anniversary with a lady having the same character, so I am well documented.
Sorry for this rather long introduction, actually - in the frame of the LENR Review, I want to tell what I accept and what I NOT reject but replace with other ideas in and for the Ed Storms's LENR theory.
Ed says:
"nuclear reactions do not and can not be made to occur in a normal chemical structure without applied energy..."
"for LENR to take place, something very unusual must form in the material as the site of the fusion process, i.e. the NAE..."
"N.A.E. is rare condition..."
I agree 120% with the first two statements and 100% with the third. Justification: I have arrived to similar conclusions- active sites- as Ed. However the third condition is a reality that has to be changed- there are no technologies based on rare conditions.
Simplifying i.e. condensing and anticipating a bit, Ed's theses can be re-formulated in
-LENR does not take place in ordinary matter
- LENR before being nuclear physics is smart materials science;
We have to learn and apply the science and art of NAE-genesis.
Now everything depends on the nature of those N.A.E.; what and how can they be?
Edmund Storms has given a surprising answer:
"if the nuclear reactions cannot take place in ordinary matter, they must happen in extraordinary voids"
The reason is obvious- the local axiom in PdD based on solid experimental data is that the excess heat is correlated with formation oh helium and the D+D =He is considered the source of excess heat, fusion can take place in a free space.
This is an explosive subject but is there absolute certainty of DIRECT fusion?
OK, let's better continue..if this is true then the hydroton has to be invoked for a mechanism of deuterium fusion. For H+H=D it is possible in principle, but in direct contradiction with Piantelli et al 's many experimental results and it seems the Rossi process is also - different.
I have opted long ago for nuclear reactions taking place in extraordinary matter.
It is so well known and i have learned a lot from Piantelli- the magic stuff is nanostructures with properties that are very different from those of the bulk material,.it is both a science and an art to know what these differences are and how to make them useful for your specific scientific technological task- in this case energy generation.
. Nanostructures is more a generic term that does not describe the exact structure for obtaining discrete energy levels and not energy bands- better also for showing the exchange and correlation energies. More simply told, the structures’s behavior has to be thus of giant atoms
Good nanostructures seem to be a necessary but still not sufficient condition of massive excess heat. How they actually work- nanoplasminics has to be included. The structures are quantum domains in which many things become possible- as the collective nuclear phenomena described by Urutskoev.
PdD and NiH may be different LENR variants. Or not - to finish in an optimist manner.
c) Randy Mills' possible BLPgeddon is coming Thursday
Comment from one of his supporters:
http://egooutpeters.blogspot.ro/2016/01/jan-23-2016-its-better-for-lenr-if-pdd.html?showComment=1453694051648#c1504360708647396099
DAILY NEWS
1) Andrea Rossi
January 24th, 2016 at 9:16 PM
Joe:
Sunday, 09.15 p.m. of Jan 24 2016:
1MW E-Cat good girl: allows me to watch the Panthers, fingers crossed.
E-Cat X resisting to the destructive attempt, good sign.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
http://bishophill.squarespace.com/discussion/post/2564294
4) Stepan Demura: Rossi's generator energetic revolution Степан Демура. Генератор Росси - энергетическая революция. Daily Reporter 24 http://dailyreporter24.com/archives/86210/
5) Paul Mahler at LENR Forum has discovered an 2013 LENR paper by Mahadeva Srinivasan:
"FOCAL THEME : BUILDING AN ECOLOGICALLY SUSTAINABLE SOCIETY" (Social Science Abstracts - Volume XXXVII, 2013 )
by INDIAN ACADEMY OF SOCIAL SCIENCES INDIA
it is the papers of the "XXXVII Indian Social Science Congress"
amu.ac.in/newevent/event/9861.pdf
at pages 61-63 there is an article by Mahadeva Srinivasan on LENR
6) Energy Prices Collapse, World in Chaos
LENR IN CONTEXT-1
What Comes After The Information Age? The Energy Age?
What Comes After The Information Age? The Energy Age?
LENR IN CONTEXT -2
Tanmay Vora describes LENR's future leader
Leadership: Start With Trust
Tanmay Vora describes LENR's future leader
Leadership: Start With Trust
The 8 I's of Infinite Innovation LENR must do this for the next 30 years!
Peter, there is no 'real' Mary Yugo. She appears as a fabrication of a propaganda machine that is intent on spreading discord via outrageous lies and worse. If Mary really existed in a formother than a graceless troll then photographs and comfirmable references would be readily available to all, even a Wikipedia page would exist. The same goes for Axil who seems to be a fabricated counter character to troll Mary in the 'cold' fusion 'war'. No it is not a lenr war, it is a 'cold war' as clearly evidenced by the propensity of propaganda. Please don't commit intellectual seppuku if Rossi fails, rather refocus your useful verve and wonderful life force that you so graciously share with us all onto cold fusion.
ReplyDeletePeter, there is no 'real' Mary Yugo. She appears as a fabrication of a propaganda machine that is intent on spreading discord via outrageous lies and worse. If Mary really existed in a formother than a graceless troll then photographs and comfirmable references would be readily available to all, even a Wikipedia page would exist. The same goes for Axil who seems to be a fabricated counter character to troll Mary in the 'cold' fusion 'war'. No it is not a lenr war, it is a 'cold war' as clearly evidenced by the propensity of propaganda. Please don't commit intellectual seppuku if Rossi fails, rather refocus your useful verve and wonderful life force that you so graciously share with us all onto cold fusion.
ReplyDeleteWith or without Rossi I am worried for the future of cold fusion. But much more without him.
DeleteThank you for your kind words.Nice as always.
Peter
Demonized?
ReplyDeleteC'mon Peter. LENR is nonsense nobody cares about and Rossi is a vermin, harmful only to fools with big pockets and a small brain.
Use a civilized language, if you are able to.What do you gain by insulting people?
DeletePeter
Hello Peter
ReplyDeleteI exchanged a couple of E mails with M.Y
I think she is as real as A.R
I wish we could get off this is Rossi for real debate.
Start thinking more business like.
Take a chance that Rossi Technology will work
and how to make money from it.
The type of thinking that made America.
Do you have any ideas.
Sam
Dear Sam,
DeleteNot a bad idea, MY actually Georgie Hody is not stupid and not evil just he has chosen a role and plays it.
His weakness is technological culture, has not lead or executed a Research and Development action. His strong side is maeasurements.But you can discuss with him
Investment is a possibility (have no ideas about how much you can invest) Not interesting for me I am finnacially independent if no Crisis comes but cannot invest.
Wish you courage and success
Peter
Dear Sam,
DeleteNot a bad idea, MY actually Georgie Hody is not stupid and not evil just he has chosen a role and plays it.
His weakness is technological culture, has not lead or executed a Research and Development action. His strong side is maeasurements.But you can discuss with him
Investment is a possibility (have no ideas about how much you can invest) Not interesting for me I am finnacially independent if no Crisis comes but cannot invest.
Wish you courage and success
Peter
Hello Peter
ReplyDeleteWhy would he want to
play the role of Mary Yugo.
Congratulations on your
50th WA
Sam
Making justice, fighting for the truth, debunking the evil.
DeleteMY will explain you.
Thanks, WA will be (we hope) on Feb 19.
Peter
Hello Peter
ReplyDeleteTom Darden and Rossi should make
a gutsy move and ask MY to be part of
the 3rd party doing the measurements
on the ECAT.
Sam
dear Sam,
Deleteif they have a well developed sense of humor, yes!
However MY has to come with real identity
peter
Hello Peter
ReplyDeleteYou said M.Y.was identified as Georgie Hody
a expert in measurements.
Know one would be laughing if he found Positive
measurements with the E CAT including Georgie.
They would be celebrating.
If negative Georgie could say I told you so.
I think he would be perfect for the job.
Sam