tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-326167780677397310.post7316735040621364760..comments2024-03-27T21:35:04.988-07:00Comments on EGO OUT: APR 11, 2016 HOW TO FINISH THE VUCA ORGY NOW HELD IN LENR.Georgina Popescuhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/04628821029016016988noreply@blogger.comBlogger5125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-326167780677397310.post-2451826237663066552016-04-12T04:29:59.563-07:002016-04-12T04:29:59.563-07:00Mr Clarke - what Industrial Heat and Tom Dardan ar...Mr Clarke - what Industrial Heat and Tom Dardan are doing to Dr Rossi is not about Science its about money and Control of a billion dollar new energy source. Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-326167780677397310.post-5461092160904808582016-04-12T03:09:02.878-07:002016-04-12T03:09:02.878-07:00Dear Tom,
Only the multiple analyses can solve th...Dear Tom,<br /><br />Only the multiple analyses can solve the problem.And these have to include the morphology aspects the structure of the areas with more or less isotopic changes.<br />No shift, story over for a long time.<br />PeterAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-326167780677397310.post-50055190295599820672016-04-11T10:49:55.457-07:002016-04-11T10:49:55.457-07:00"I trust the results of the Lugano just becau..."I trust the results of the Lugano just because there were observed isotopic shifts."<br /><br />That is not logical. The excess heat results are just wrong. the testers misunderstood how to do thermography on Alumina. And my recalculation is quantitatively self-validating because the claimed "acceleration in COP" vanishes more precisely than would be possible if there was a mistake.<br /><br />Independently, you make a judgement over whether Rossi's ash sample from Lugano is contaminated. But even if it valid, and thus an indicator of LENR, that cannot change the math showing those Lugano observations consistent with an electric heater COP = 1.Tom Clarkehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08786618190262592330noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-326167780677397310.post-74602548202544350722016-04-11T10:42:50.645-07:002016-04-11T10:42:50.645-07:00Peter - I respect your emotional commitment to LEN...Peter - I respect your emotional commitment to LENR. I think perhaps you are making a big mistake here traducing IH, or at least giving some room for Rossi to do so. IH will likely be a major LENR funder over the years to come and that from Darden's philanthropy.<br /><br />"We are working now with imponderables, approximations false superlatives- sanctifications vs. demonizations, replacing facts (that are only guessed) with impressions, moral values as character, reputation, mixing in past, charm, charisma, anecdotes"<br /><br />I agree - much of the flak is speculative and unsubstantive.<br /><br />However the facts about the Rossi tests that supports IH's PR are real. The fact that Penon writes reports that show he is not qualified as a tester is not imponderable, impression, character. It is simply that his report from july-Aug 2012 e-cat testing is very very poor quality. There are technical issues, like the way that what was left out could account for the apparent excess heat, but the defects in his test methodology are so glaring the cannot be denied. If you do not accept this I will happily post a short summary here with a link to the report so that everyone can validate it for themselves.<br /><br />I won't repeat the issues about Lugano - they are highly technical and were addressed by me in writing more than 6 months ago. Since then no-one has been able to challenge my refutation - it is maths not imponderable, not impression, not character.<br /><br />Rossi, according to his actions, respects nothing except his self-interest. You cannot in the interest of good PR for LENR smooth over the proven defects in his published test reports because it comes back to hurt people like Darden who do not deserve that.Tom Clarkehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08786618190262592330noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-326167780677397310.post-70830694573728067332016-04-11T10:30:45.357-07:002016-04-11T10:30:45.357-07:00"This is simple and straightforward- excess h..."This is simple and straightforward- excess heat and isotopic shifts, bound by a cause-effect relationship are Siamese twins. Isotopic shifts are MEASURABLE aand unassailable- the central piece in the forensic drama. Heat measurements are already attacked - air can be injected in the steam, but mass spectrometry results coming from Rossi, IH and the ERV repeatable in tens of labs- are rock solid."<br /><br />I agree. But Rossi has only ever had two sets of isotopic shift results. the first one caused quite a storm here showing that Ni had been converted to Cu. Skeptics pointed out that the isotopic fractions were all natural. Rossi however continued to fine the results "interesting" - they supported his current theory for e-cat operation. Three years later Rossi admitted that the ash was "contaminated". He never said this at the time.<br /><br />So the second (Lugano) sample of ash from Rossi can really not be trusted. It too could be contaminated, in this case with the bought 62Ni that we knew Rossi was using (at one time) as fuel.<br /><br />That is the non-technical argument. There is then the technical argument. 98% conversion to 62Ni has remarkably implausible whatever reactions might be happening. And it would have to be 98% conversion of only a small part of the Ni - because otehrwise the excess heat just from the Ni conversion would be far in excess of what was found.<br /><br />When you look technically at the isotopic shifts they fall apart. Since LENR is extraordinary and not understood you can always make a set of assumptions that allow 62Ni with LENR. But they are very contrived.<br /><br />I'll happily lead you through why that is if you like.<br /><br />Many people were hoping for MFMP isotopic shift results and I agree that if they discovered such it would be very significant. But they have not, so this box thus far remains unticked.<br /><br />Tom Clarkehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08786618190262592330noreply@blogger.com